Comments on: MY ANTI TIME LOOP THEORY http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/ A place to write and read Lost Theories Thu, 17 May 2012 19:43:17 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: Mamey http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1815 Mamey Tue, 17 Feb 2009 17:39:22 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1815 Well, guess you were right after all Cappayne, "This place is death" answered that question for us all. Lol. It was an intresting way of getting sick with the smokey being involved though (that's my interpretation of the sickness). Actually, I believe that once smokey kills anyone, they can represent them physically, specifically, I infered that Robert wasn't him at all (he was dead), and instead it was smokey in person or flesh (or at least a part of him, as I believe we can still find him around the island eventhough he is representing someone). Thoughts anyone? Well, guess you were right after all Cappayne, “This place is death” answered that question for us all. Lol.
It was an intresting way of getting sick with the smokey being involved though (that’s my interpretation of the sickness). Actually, I believe that once smokey kills anyone, they can represent them physically, specifically, I infered that Robert wasn’t him at all (he was dead), and instead it was smokey in person or flesh (or at least a part of him, as I believe we can still find him around the island eventhough he is representing someone).
Thoughts anyone?

]]> By: cappayne http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1483 cappayne Wed, 11 Feb 2009 23:01:23 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1483 I disagree that Rousseau and co. will start jumping with Jin. I think Jin will jump with Sawyer and co. (as I think he has already been doing) and after a few more flashes he will reunite with them. I disagree that Rousseau and co. will start jumping with Jin. I think Jin will jump with Sawyer and co. (as I think he has already been doing) and after a few more flashes he will reunite with them.

]]> By: Mamey http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1482 Mamey Wed, 11 Feb 2009 22:54:26 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1482 Ups, sorry dude, I was just reading your post again, and saw my mistake: you said SHE not HE (meaning Charlotte). Either way, it is too ambigous to say that by just seeing kate or hearing daniel say that he loves her, that they have the constant. The deal is much more complex: it requires someone to have something or someone that exists in EVERY scenario of time skipping (for desmong it was the present and the past, caz he time skipped between only twi places or times). Therefore, it is necesary for someone to have something or someone that exists ALWAYS in every time reference. it could be what you are saying though, just pointing out that it is a little too ambigous or weak argument. Ups, sorry dude, I was just reading your post again, and saw my mistake: you said SHE not HE (meaning Charlotte).

Either way, it is too ambigous to say that by just seeing kate or hearing daniel say that he loves her, that they have the constant. The deal is much more complex: it requires someone to have something or someone that exists in EVERY scenario of time skipping (for desmong it was the present and the past, caz he time skipped between only twi places or times). Therefore, it is necesary for someone to have something or someone that exists ALWAYS in every time reference.
it could be what you are saying though, just pointing out that it is a little too ambigous or weak argument.

]]> By: Mamey http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1469 Mamey Wed, 11 Feb 2009 21:13:14 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1469 acharaisthekey , you said someting which is wrong (respects): -quote- "HOwever, with the island spinning the group around, if no constants are established (and by Daniel saying he loved Charlotte, she now has a constant, by Sawyer seeing Kate, he know has a constant, and we acharaisthekey , you said someting which is wrong (respects):

-quote- “HOwever, with the island spinning the group around, if no constants are established (and by Daniel saying he loved Charlotte, she now has a constant, by Sawyer seeing Kate, he know has a constant, and we

]]> By: rlsundberg http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1250 rlsundberg Tue, 10 Feb 2009 18:22:18 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1250 I'll take it one step further. I believe their sickness occurs because they actually start jumping with Jin... Guess we'll find out in two days if that happens or not. It seems obvious that the French team dies off for this reason. The island sends them through time and virtually all of them die off except Danielle and her baby... but when that happens is the question. I’ll take it one step further. I believe their sickness occurs because they actually start jumping with Jin… Guess we’ll find out in two days if that happens or not. It seems obvious that the French team dies off for this reason. The island sends them through time and virtually all of them die off except Danielle and her baby… but when that happens is the question.

]]> By: Mamey http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1091 Mamey Mon, 09 Feb 2009 04:54:42 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1091 Hi, I'm new here, so if anyone already posted what i'm about to, please understand why it happended. I have a theory regarding the events on the latest episode "the little prince": As you recall, at the episode's end, we have a look at Danielle's french team. Now, if you also recall, Danielle used to say to the Losties that her team was victim of what they called a sort of "sickness", they went crazy, and thus they died eventually. Well, I have a theory on what they actualy happened to them. I believe that everything that is going to happen during this time skips has already happened, ad cannot happened either way, it is the past. Therefore, Danielle's team actually arrived at the island the same way we are shown at the end of the episode (with some people having time skips and later having nose bleeds). So, I think that the so called "sickness" is actually the same thing the Losties (or some of them to be correct) are living (Miles, Charllote and Juliet's nose bleeding). This is the escence of the danger the people of the island are living, that is the sickness Danielle mentioned, and what will kill every one of those having this sickness if not stoped (whatever is causing that). So, in short, the same problem some of the Losties are having with the time travel is the same "sickness" Danielle's team had, and that is why they had the "sickness", cuz they arrived at the island in 1988, but with the island skiping through space and time for some of them. Hi, I’m new here, so if anyone already posted what i’m about to, please understand why it happended.

I have a theory regarding the events on the latest episode “the little prince”:

As you recall, at the episode’s end, we have a look at Danielle’s french team. Now, if you also recall, Danielle used to say to the Losties that her team was victim of what they called a sort of “sickness”, they went crazy, and thus they died eventually.
Well, I have a theory on what they actualy happened to them. I believe that everything that is going to happen during this time skips has already happened, ad cannot happened either way, it is the past. Therefore, Danielle’s team actually arrived at the island the same way we are shown at the end of the episode (with some people having time skips and later having nose bleeds). So, I think that the so called “sickness” is actually the same thing the Losties (or some of them to be correct) are living (Miles, Charllote and Juliet’s nose bleeding).
This is the escence of the danger the people of the island are living, that is the sickness Danielle mentioned, and what will kill every one of those having this sickness if not stoped (whatever is causing that).

So, in short, the same problem some of the Losties are having with the time travel is the same “sickness” Danielle’s team had, and that is why they had the “sickness”, cuz they arrived at the island in 1988, but with the island skiping through space and time for some of them.

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1057 A.E.S. Sun, 08 Feb 2009 02:44:56 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1057 But what I do think is, for what its worth, John Locke is finally starting to believe that he is the one who is supposed to lead the others. I think it was a huge turning point for Locke, and his real purpose is yet to come. I really think we will see him come out of his shell and be the man who he is destined to be...lets just hope its not just a tool for use of Ben returning. But what I do think is, for what its worth, John Locke is finally starting to believe that he is the one who is supposed to lead the others. I think it was a huge turning point for Locke, and his real purpose is yet to come. I really think we will see him come out of his shell and be the man who he is destined to be…lets just hope its not just a tool for use of Ben returning.

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1055 A.E.S. Sun, 08 Feb 2009 02:41:50 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1055 Honestly cappayne, the thought ran through my head, but the way Locke reacted to his name when he first heard it, changed my mind. Honestly cappayne, the thought ran through my head, but the way Locke reacted to his name when he first heard it, changed my mind.

]]> By: cappayne http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1015 cappayne Sat, 07 Feb 2009 05:10:27 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1015 AES: With you thinking that Locke knows more than we think, and his connections to the island and such, do you think that when he chooses not to shoot the Other (who we find out is Whidmore), he lied when he told Sawyer he did not shoot "because he's one of my people" and instead he KNEW that Whidmore could not die because of future events (just like Michael and Locke could not die)? AES: With you thinking that Locke knows more than we think, and his connections to the island and such, do you think that when he chooses not to shoot the Other (who we find out is Whidmore), he lied when he told Sawyer he did not shoot “because he’s one of my people” and instead he KNEW that Whidmore could not die because of future events (just like Michael and Locke could not die)?

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/02/my-anti-time-loop-theory/#comment-1012 A.E.S. Sat, 07 Feb 2009 02:28:51 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=340#comment-1012 OK, heres the deal.I WILL AGREE WITH YOU NOT GETTING MY IDEA OF OTHER CHARACTERS going through the time loop. here is a few examples of 'who' I feel is looping or has looped and why. before i do. i would just like to say that i hope you understand my ...loop definition, if you will. I do not agree that the show is a neverending timeloop, and that its the "big" mystery of the show. what i do think is that 'certain characters' that actually loop. I believe that Desmond loops, not for an eternity, but at least for one portion of his life. I believe that Faraday loops, my reasoning is because of his boo-hooing at the site of seeing the plane wreckage on the news..not to mention that he has been experimenting with time travel, but more for the first reason. There are a few others that i believe are, but they are arguable, and i know I'll lose those battles against YOU. The one who we have not seen loop, but I am the most certain he is John Locke. to say that it is chance or coincidence that Locke has so many...connections with the island is crazy to me. To say that it is because he wants there to be certain things on island that he is destined to see, or do is also an issue. and yes , someone could have told him these things out of scene or in his past,and that is an understandable explanation, that would relate to time travel and not 'looping'. so if you think that I'll give you that one. but one thing that is unexplainable, that I and maybe even you Achara, cannot explain. How in the hell, would a human being, no matter instincts or ability, know exactly when it is going to start or stop raining? Call it a reach, but I dont know what else to ask. were not in the same boat as far as the changing vs creating idea. but i just dont need the producers to tell me that Locke has done this before to figure out how the guy knew it was going to rain. and dont get upset...for i am very stubborn, yet open minded. you may not ever lean my way, but I may at least give to you a little with the right words. i awit your reply my friend. OK, heres the deal.I WILL AGREE WITH YOU NOT GETTING MY IDEA OF OTHER CHARACTERS going through the time loop. here is a few examples of ‘who’ I feel is looping or has looped and why.
before i do. i would just like to say that i hope you understand my …loop definition, if you will. I do not agree that the show is a neverending timeloop, and that its the “big” mystery of the show. what i do think is that ‘certain characters’ that actually loop. I believe that Desmond loops, not for an eternity, but at least for one portion of his life. I believe that Faraday loops, my reasoning is because of his boo-hooing at the site of seeing the plane wreckage on the news..not to mention that he has been experimenting with time travel, but more for the first reason.
There are a few others that i believe are, but they are arguable, and i know I’ll lose those battles against YOU.
The one who we have not seen loop, but I am the most certain he is John Locke. to say that it is chance or coincidence that Locke has so many…connections with the island is crazy to me. To say that it is because he wants there to be certain things on island that he is destined to see, or do is also an issue. and yes , someone could have told him these things out of scene or in his past,and that is an understandable explanation, that would relate to time travel and not ‘looping’. so if you think that I’ll give you that one. but one thing that is unexplainable, that I and maybe even you Achara, cannot explain. How in the hell, would a human being, no matter instincts or ability, know exactly when it is going to start or stop raining? Call it a reach, but I dont know what else to ask.
were not in the same boat as far as the changing vs creating idea. but i just dont need the producers to tell me that Locke has done this before to figure out how the guy knew it was going to rain. and dont get upset…for i am very stubborn, yet open minded. you may not ever lean my way, but I may at least give to you a little with the right words. i awit your reply my friend.

]]>