chill out, dissagreeing with your theory, whether based on proof (which is hrd to come by) or just on gut feeling is not an attack on you!

you seem to be a nice young man with a happy smily face, don’t let your love of lost turn you crazy!!

have an early night, then 2 more days until lost

Im looking for the answer of Lost im not trying to make what I want try and fit the best I can which is what alot of you seem to be doing. Your not theorising about the show and backing it up with evidence. Your saying what you want to happen and you won’t accept it any other way. Like i’ve said countless times I personally don’t want a loop theory to exist unless we find out they have previously been in a loop and this time its going to be different just because i dont want the ending scene to be the same as the opening……THAT WOULD BE RUBBISH.

HOWEVER just because I think its rubbish and I don’t want it to happen doesn’t mean it couldn’t. Therefore I will happily theorise about the prospect until hard evidence is given against. If you comment saying you just don’t like it but you have no reason then – its ur gut instinct – you dont want it to happen like that – or for any other reason then proving it with evidence then please don’t bother. If you can prove my theories wrong with evidence then I will quite happily listen because I would love to hear something that actually disproves the loop theory. Until then just don’t post your ‘feelings’ unless you ave already proved to me of your theory worthiness ie AES, Dabs, username etc you will know if your in this list because I will get along with you and have discussions about the show. Basically in the end you need to be open minded to be a theorist otherwise you’ll just have one theory and when its proved wrong you’ll be well and truely screwed. Good day to you sir.

i’d love to be more structured in my response, but there is no real reason behind these thoughts other than a gut instict.

i may be wrong, sorry this ost is a bit of a waste of time

i usally agree with highbrow and in this case i do

THANX.

When Sarah was in the car accident she was in one car, while Shannons father was in the other.

They were two random strangers who’s cars collided with each other.

The fact that it was Shannons father in the other car was purely another one of those Lost “coincidences”.

But that doesn’t explain how Shannon is Jacks sister-in-law?

oompa:Dont you think its weird he does all the things he says to her in the future? maybe he does it cause he knows he does or maybe he does it cause he said it & is keeping his promise?

As for the extra booze he recieves IDK just seems strange to me to save one but thats just me, I would have pounded them all and prob caused the plane crash myself PARTY!!!!!!!!!!

Oh yeah i forgot about your Question about Jack marrying Boone??? if you remember in a “past-life clip of Jack” when he gets two people rushed in ER, A man & a woman & has to decide who to help first & he chooses the girl which turns out to be sarah(he then later marry’s) Jack lets her father die but only cause he saves Sarah first. Shannon came with the Wife (Shannons step-mom)so if im wrong then my bad.

BiNG, isn’t Shannon Boone’s sister? Did Jack marry Boone and I missed it?
I’m confused, I don’t remember any other Shannon.
I think that in Jack’s situation, I, too, would have said that I’d keep Rose company ’til her husband came back and would reassure her just like he did, as anyone would.

What’s suspicious to me is the stewardess offering him the 2 bottles, not that he didn’t drink both of them right there. He wasn’t a drunken mess there yet.
Still, I agree and have no explanation for Jack’s strange behavior after supposedly “hiding in the bushes” from Smokey.