Comments on: “TIME LOOP” PROOF?

By: BiNG

BiNG — Sun, 12 Apr 2009 00:35:49 +0000

? lets what you think Josh…i just figured you were writing the theory or should i say question about the canoes?

By: BiNG

BiNG — Sat, 11 Apr 2009 23:08:33 +0000

if u already commented this expect me to write back this time…while most ur ideas tryin to crush my ideas are just as crazy & filled with just as many holes.

By: BiNG

BiNG — Sat, 11 Apr 2009 23:06:39 +0000

OK Josh, & anybody else

ONLY if you want…read this 800+ word theory i conjured up & correct my mistakes or give your honest opinion about it…im gonna shower real quick then then burn some cells then be back shortly…im still waitin to see about our other discussion on the canoes, be prepared to lose.

By: BiNG

BiNG — Sat, 11 Apr 2009 08:47:00 +0000

HAhahaha i read some of the comments again on my theory and i got some answers for some peep.

Wesley hanks for holdin my theory together you mostly did but as for everyone else they just kind of dismissed most info with other facts idk maybe its just me.

No one mentions the flash’s being significant to the future un-folding perfectly almost scripted.

BIGDAVe are you seriously basing your argument & reasoning for Jack finding Charlie so fast is cause its “natural to run uphill the Easy way? upHILL? ok & through tree’s what man?

As for charlie being in PTSD i understand that but you didnt explain why Desmond had to save charlie so much?? cause he should be dead. & oh Gee he is dead(kinda)now so seems like destiny to me & take in account how many times charlie almost dies??? try

By: bejayel

bejayel — Thu, 26 Mar 2009 02:10:23 +0000

Charlotte remembers Faraday because she lived with him at the dharma initiative for a while when he travelled back in time.

The is no time loop. Taking random quotes and using them out of context doesnt prove anything. There is abolutely no evidence for a time loop and countless pieces of evidence that there isnt.

By: TehIgnored

TehIgnored — Thu, 26 Mar 2009 00:08:43 +0000

I see nothing that proves an actual “Loop” only time travel. Something happening “just in the right moment” doesn’t prove anything in regards to time loops, it could very much just prove providence.

By: lost4815162342

lost4815162342 — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 19:21:41 +0000

What is interesting about what you posted is that Charlotte remembers Faraday. Which means she ALREADY has memories which result from Faraday travelling into the past. I think you give one point to “Whatever happens, happens”. This gets confusing. I bet the continuity guys on this show are going crazy by now.

By: Wesley

Wesley — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 18:59:01 +0000

so you mean abit like the Sopranos ending if you watched it…..everyone expecting him to be killed in the cafe at the end and it just fades to black for like a minute haha….them endings even though we hate them are the best. Just think about it if the writers did that what are the viewers really gna do????? Stop watching a programme that has alredy ended???? We couldn’t do anyting but piss n moan about it. Depends how the writers get their kicks really.

By: bejayel

bejayel — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 18:58:48 +0000

I havent seen teh first season in a while, but if i remember correctly, Jack had absolutely no idea who a fair portion of the people / objects were. It knew nothing or rousseau or the Black Rock. He claimed that there was no “monster”. He didnt know who ben was, nor did he know what would happen if they stopped entering the numbers.

Sorry dude, Jack is not stuck in a time loop.

By: Wesley

Wesley — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 18:55:42 +0000

I didn’t say that I’m saying he’s the only one who has memories out of the losties. For example Richard could also be in the same predicament. Hence why he never ages. All just speculation of course….but thats where all the best theorys start off.