Comments on: Kate is Preggo! (Oceanic 815/Ajira 316 Parallel)

By: KateyIsLOST

KateyIsLOST — Thu, 24 Dec 2009 17:23:48 +0000

Mindefflost–actually I did notice that too, and I thought the same thing. But I hadn’t seen that episode yet when I wrote this so. I think the evidence for Kate is much more significant but I’m definitely on board for the Juliet theory too. Maybe it is both of them. Maybe Kate will have a little dark-haired baby boy and Juliet will have a little blonde boy if you get where I’m going….:O

By: Mindefflost

Mindefflost — Wed, 23 Dec 2009 18:18:29 +0000

I think it is actually Juliet that’s pregnant. Or maybe both. But did anyone else notice that weird moment when Juliet, Jack and Kate run into Rose and Bernard? She stops and lingers as they are leaving, with her hand placed on ther stomach in aweird “I’m actually pregnant” kinda way.

Just saying.

By: mrslinus700

mrslinus700 — Wed, 06 May 2009 13:21:20 +0000

I think you’re right. I just dont see why else they would have made it such a point to show that totally random and out of place sex scene the night before they left. It stuck out like a sore thumb, and that’s a good indication that there’s a deeper meaning there.

plus, as tambatism said, “She

By: KateyIsLOST

KateyIsLOST — Tue, 21 Apr 2009 00:53:17 +0000

tambatism: didn’t see your sidenote about the sidenote, heehe! But yeah, I totally agree–that’s exactly what I think too and what I’m hoping for. I definitely think that the Incident is going to involve several ongoing mysteries including the the 108-minute button, the pregnancy thing and maybe how a few of the Losties stories end. Like I said in my above post, if the Kate preggo thing is true, then I’m hoping it’s not one of those “yeah, Kate’s a mommy” happy-ending things–I want imagine it as a major part of the issues and hopefully some long-awaited mayhem and insanity and turmoil. Hehehehe. It shall definitely be interesting!

By: KateyIsLOST

KateyIsLOST — Mon, 20 Apr 2009 23:52:35 +0000

Hm, the only problem with the Sayid theory is that–yes–she does know why she came back, and so do we. She states that she’s “going back to find Claire”. That whole episode sort of led up to that revealing statement so I’m pretty sure it wasn’t a lie. Besides, she really didn’t seem that bummed at all when she found Sawyer, he looked sort of confused but in every scene with her looking at Sawyer it always seemed sort of like a “hey old buddy–funny how things turned out?” sort of way not a “how are you with Juliet? I came back here to find you!” sort of way.

PLUS. She states several times back on the island that she has nothing to go back for and quite honestly she seems sincere in that. Remember that scene where Jack was like “We have to go back Kate!” and she backed up her little cute compact vehicle into the parking lot, got her angry face and screamed at Jack for even mentioning that she should go back. She definitely made it clear that she had her heart broken by JACK and that all she had wanted was to live a normal life there, away from the island.

But even besides that, she stated clearly that her reason for going to back was to find Claire. Unless she was somehow lying which honestly seems ridiculous, that’s the end of that.

And I never saw anything even remotely resembling the idea that Kate still wants Sawyer. I quite honestly don’t think she ever loved him very deeply, I think she wanted to love him because she knew she was really in love with Jack but couldn’t get over all the baggage that came with that and so she wanted to love Sawyer, loved him to a degree but I don’t think it was ever anything more than something she had needed at the time. I think she loves him more like a best friend because he’s always there for her in ways that Jack can’t be because he understands that whole “convict” thing.

Maybe I missed something but I reallly don’t see any more Skate hints from Kate’s end. Sawyer–yes. Kate…she seems pretty done.

I agree that Kate with Aaron was annoying–it was just so out of character for her to be all lovey-dovey, but I think it was meant to show that that whole thing was wrong. Her and Jack weren’t meant to be Aaron’s parents and to act like such changed them both a great deal. I haven’t really thought very much about what it would be like for her to have a kid–ever since I realized this idea of her filling Claire’s role on the second plane, I imagined her either dying and starting the curse, having some huge dramatic something in regards to the baby being taken permanently, or it kidnapped or killed or something like that—I never imagined a scenario in which both Kate and the baby actually survive. I don’t know why, hm. I’ll have to contemplate that more.

I always imagined that this would be a very, very negative plot point for Kate. If it does happen and they both survive and Kate ends up being all mommy-like right of the bat then I’m going to be super disappointed. Thinking up this theory I was imagining chaos and character turmoil. I’m still hoping.

By: tambatism

tambatism — Mon, 20 Apr 2009 23:40:02 +0000

Random side note reply: In my opinion, I believe that the sidenote directly relates to the birth/pregnancy problems that the others face in the future. Most likely, after the incident, women who are pregnant die. Maybe radiation or whatever because of the electromagnetism/whatever.

That isn’t actually a random side note though, because IF KATE IS PREGNANT, aaand the incident is directly related to (or actually, the root cause of) the pregnancy problems on the island post-incident, then it should be interesting to see what happens to Kate and her baby, yes?

By: tambatism

tambatism — Mon, 20 Apr 2009 23:34:23 +0000

kateyislost = read above, the other comment I left… I explained how Kate could have been playing the part of Sayid in returning to the island (going after a loved one – Sawyer – like Sayid was going after Nadia), just as Sayid was playing her role as the fugitive. I explained it but everyone kind of skipped over it because they so desperately want Kate to be pregnant.

On the one hand, having a baby would probably make Kate more INTERESTING, but on the other hand, how annoying was Claire about “theyre trying to take my baby!”??? I can imagine Kate being similar, but worse. Also, the way she was about/with Aaron was very annoying, I think that Kate’s character as a mother would just be worse than she already is now. Granted, it would give her more depth than just a promiscuis woman who can’t decide if she wants Jack or Sawyer, but I think it would also have its major downsides.

No one is discussing the downsides of if Kate were to be pregnant.

Major upside, though — She’d be closer to Jack and get off Sawyer’s dick already. Honestly, he’s with Juliet, she just wants what she doesn’t/can’t have.

By: KateyIsLOST

KateyIsLOST — Mon, 20 Apr 2009 22:31:27 +0000

How would you define “Sayid’s part”? I don’t really remember it. To me it would make her less annoying I think, even though I like her as a character because she’s insane I’ve definitely been annoyed by her for the last…eh…three seasons. She was way better in season one when she was still sort of reserved and “outcasty” but, anyway. I think her being pregnant would bring out a really crazy side of her again since it’s apparently something she’s been very freaked out about in the past AND it’s something she can’t just run from which would probably send her over the edge. I love characters that are crazy! She’s been far too normal lately…same thing with Sawyer. I was so happy when Jack went cataclysmic! Ah that was great! Sawyer being all heroic makes me sad.

I think it would be soo great if Kate was pregnant because there’s a good chance at least four people would probably go off their rockers (Kate because she’d be pregnant, Jack because it’d be his, Sawyer because he’s confused about the whole “her” thing, and Juliet because she’d think she’s going to start killing babies again and because this time it’d be someone close to home on two accounts).

Another thing that adds evidence to this theory is the whole pregnancy/Juliet issue–we know it has to begin at some point between the hippee-losties’ time and the 815 losties’ time so I think we’re going to get an explanation soon. And someone has to get pregnant in order for the curse to begin. I dunno but I think it’s comin’. Even if it’s not Kate, it’s gotta be someone.

On a random sidenote: I can’t wait to see the answer to the Incident. Mmmm, it’s gonna be beautiful!

By: tambatism

tambatism — Mon, 20 Apr 2009 20:58:02 +0000

I still think she could have been playing Sayid’s part on 316, I want to believe she’s pregnant, but at the same time that would make Kate SO MUCH MORE ANNOYING. It’s possible we’re just reading way too much into it.

By: KateyIsLOST

KateyIsLOST — Sun, 19 Apr 2009 18:40:32 +0000

Maybe the reason Claire had to hang with Christian in the cabin was so that Aaron would go with Kate. Maybe the island sort of knew that things had to happen that way in order for them to come back because if you think about it, Aaron is the reason Kate settled down and didn’t go galavanting over the globe again (in which case there’s about a 90% chance she would have landed in prison with triple life sentences). And it’s because of Aaron that Jack went crazy and became a druggie and that he and Kate became astranged. I mean think about it–they were all adament that they were not going back to the island under any circumstances ever…if they had been able to have a happy life together without Jack freaking out over his nephew/stepson/thing the neither of them would have gotten desperate enough to actually consider going back. I guess Aaron was sort of the catalyst for that–Claire had to let him go so that he could send everyone back. And also, if my theory is correct then the night Kate gets pregnant is the night she’s given up Aaron–if that hadn’t happened she would not have had any reason to do her sad thing with Jack and she would have had no purpose for going back to the island…

It all fits. It alll fits.