Comments on: claire??

By: Sinster

Sinster — Tue, 09 Jun 2009 02:26:14 +0000

I definitely think claire is dead. I actually just finished watching the episode where she wandered off, and I also think Myles was onto the fact she was not a human the entire time he, her, Sawyer, and baby Aaron were traveling together.

By: Thorn

Thorn — Thu, 28 May 2009 15:43:17 +0000

Yeah what did Claire do wrong? In all of her flashbacks I do not remember her committing murder, wasting her life, preying on the ignorant and or innocent or anything else worthy of being guilty of the wrath of the smoke monster come judgment time.

She was going to give her child up for adoption but is this a sin? If she was incapable or raising the child properly and would have caused the child to suffer a poor quality of life I think you could argue she was doing the right thing by seeking to give your child up for adoption especially if you didn’t want the child. I can not see this as a “sin”.

By: 4815162342

4815162342 — Thu, 28 May 2009 12:09:38 +0000

I’d tend to agree with Tas on that one. It would get a bit OTT. Getting back to Claire though – If smokie killed her then it must have judjed her for something and come to the conclusion that it was so evil she had to die. Could it have been her thoughts regarding her baby – ie. giving it up? Who knows? I suppose if we make the same assumption for Christian – that he was judged and killed by ole’ smokeasaurus – that it may been as a result of his infidelities that resulted in Claires birth? Other than entertaining the thought of giving up her child, Claire’s not really done anything that bad, has she? This all seems a little too straight forward though!

By: Tas

Tas — Thu, 28 May 2009 07:04:14 +0000

I think anymore impostors and we start getting into the territory that anyone could be dead and they could all be impostors and then it gets a bit pointless and out of hand if nobody is real.

By: lostie411

lostie411 — Thu, 28 May 2009 01:35:49 +0000

But i dont know if thats even what you meant, i could have misunderstood haha.

By: lostie411

lostie411 — Thu, 28 May 2009 01:35:16 +0000

Thats a really cool connection you made with the eko and yemi thing. Because He came to Eko as smokie and killed him cause of his sims i think. Then Christian came to Clair (im guessing as smokie) an killed her, but what did she do wrong? Something with Aaron? hmmm. well i like your thinking

By: eko rocks

eko rocks — Wed, 27 May 2009 23:42:39 +0000

thanks for your comments guys. i forgot all about her getting blown up in dharmaville! also i had another thought about when imposter christian and (maybe) imposter claire were seen by real locke in the cabin. untill then if i remember correctly locke had`nt seen christian before? maybe claire was there so that locke would be convinced to do whatever imposter christian said? as locke seemed to have a bit of a softspot for her? i can`t quite remember what was said though, can somebody fill me in please?? also i can`t understand why on earth she would have left her baby son in the jungle like that in the middle of the night? thats why i`m thinking something must have happened to her?? enter imposter claie.haha

By: BanLinus

BanLinus — Wed, 27 May 2009 23:05:02 +0000

Jacks willingness to help Claire and add that to Kate’s willingness to help Claire, and who knows what that could mean if we have a Claire imposter.

By: aching_for_perfection

aching_for_perfection — Wed, 27 May 2009 21:53:29 +0000

it is a very real possiblity that claire could be dead. if she is, she probably died when the house she was in was blown up.

i think that impostor christian and yemi and locke are not the same impostor. i was reading up on the smoke monster the other day and it said that it was the smoke monster that appeared to eko as yemi. and it (yemi) wanted eko to confess his sins so he could be judged, much like the smoke monster judged ben.

as for claire, i was reading on emilie de ravin’s profile on wikipedia, and it said she will be back as a mian character in the final season.