Comments on: Jacob and his Nemesis, all you need to know http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/05/jacob-and-his-nemesis-all-you-need-to-know/ A place to write and read Lost Theories Thu, 17 May 2012 19:43:17 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: dabiatchishere http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/05/jacob-and-his-nemesis-all-you-need-to-know/#comment-17479 dabiatchishere Tue, 02 Jun 2009 04:24:57 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=5591#comment-17479 rambomb23, I totally concur with all of AES' statements! This is definitely more than worthy of being in the 'theory' section, and it is 5 out of 5, IMO. This is a brilliant theory, and a thoroughly enjoyable read!! I will certainly be making further comment. You have some great thoughts, and I look forward to hearing much more from you! rambomb23, I totally concur with all of AES’ statements! This is definitely more than worthy of being in the ‘theory’ section, and it is 5 out of 5, IMO.

This is a brilliant theory, and a thoroughly enjoyable read!!

I will certainly be making further comment.

You have some great thoughts, and I look forward to hearing much more from you!

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/05/jacob-and-his-nemesis-all-you-need-to-know/#comment-17475 A.E.S. Tue, 02 Jun 2009 03:54:16 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=5591#comment-17475 Good answers. I still carry my doubts of MIBs relationship to the monster in that way, but its as good a theory that I feel can come of it, it proven true...nice work again. Fully agree on the people Jacob/MIB brought to the island, your clarification makes me have a better understanding of your thought...and PLEASE, post in theories... You can go into your profile, scroll to the bottom, and uncheck the box "fun", and check "theories" for a quick fix... Again please do, this is easily a theory, a very good one at that, and although a "fun" list of discussion topics...I feel it is much more theory material... Good answers.

I still carry my doubts of MIBs relationship to the monster in that way, but its as good a theory that I feel can come of it, it proven true…nice work again.

Fully agree on the people Jacob/MIB brought to the island, your clarification makes me have a better understanding of your thought…and PLEASE, post in theories…

You can go into your profile, scroll to the bottom, and uncheck the box “fun”, and check “theories” for a quick fix…

Again please do, this is easily a theory, a very good one at that, and although a “fun” list of discussion topics…I feel it is much more theory material…

]]> By: rambomb23 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/05/jacob-and-his-nemesis-all-you-need-to-know/#comment-17469 rambomb23 Tue, 02 Jun 2009 03:44:04 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=5591#comment-17469 a.e.s., i actually meant to submit this under theories so youll probably see it under a similar name there soon. as for your questions... i dont think the MIB is the monster...i think i said that he can sort of reincarnate himself as the monster and utilizes that form to achieve his ends. also, jacob brought the members of the oceanic flight onto the plane to recreate the original crash as closely as possible like elouise said. he didnt, however, bring locke or ben. MIB convinced locke to die and have everyone come back through christian and richard. feel free to shoot more questions at me a.e.s., i actually meant to submit this under theories so youll probably see it under a similar name there soon. as for your questions…

i dont think the MIB is the monster…i think i said that he can sort of reincarnate himself as the monster and utilizes that form to achieve his ends. also, jacob brought the members of the oceanic flight onto the plane to recreate the original crash as closely as possible like elouise said. he didnt, however, bring locke or ben. MIB convinced locke to die and have everyone come back through christian and richard.

feel free to shoot more questions at me

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/05/jacob-and-his-nemesis-all-you-need-to-know/#comment-17448 A.E.S. Tue, 02 Jun 2009 00:08:53 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=5591#comment-17448 This is a fantasic theory. I just want to start by saying that...I do disagree with some of it, but I just want to clarify, that what you have said, is some of the best argument to my opposite beliefs that I have encountered...5 out of 5 stars easily. On that, if you read almost anything I have written hear, you will see that I am a believer in John Locke...not the one that is portrayed by MIB, but the real John Locke. I really dont want to get into huge debate hear, I am saving some of my argument for a forecoming theory, but you do put things into perspective. And if not for hard headedness in my belief that he is not a pawn, you would flip me...so very nicely done. Your answer to your own question of "What are they doing hear?"... Almost perfect, I just dont buy into the monster actually being MIB. Other than that, I love your explanation of their purpose in regards to stopping the loop...but it was Jacob that brought them there, not MIB, no? Well, hopefully you can shed some light on my disagreements, with the understanding that I think this is one of the best theories of the season...again, great job, and I'll be looking for your rebuttals when my theor arrives today or tomorrow... ;] This is a fantasic theory. I just want to start by saying that…I do disagree with some of it, but I just want to clarify, that what you have said, is some of the best argument to my opposite beliefs that I have encountered…5 out of 5 stars easily.

On that, if you read almost anything I have written hear, you will see that I am a believer in John Locke…not the one that is portrayed by MIB, but the real John Locke.

I really dont want to get into huge debate hear, I am saving some of my argument for a forecoming theory, but you do put things into perspective. And if not for hard headedness in my belief that he is not a pawn, you would flip me…so very nicely done.

Your answer to your own question of “What are they doing hear?”…

Almost perfect, I just dont buy into the monster actually being MIB. Other than that, I love your explanation of their purpose in regards to stopping the loop…but it was Jacob that brought them there, not MIB, no?

Well, hopefully you can shed some light on my disagreements, with the understanding that I think this is one of the best theories of the season…again, great job, and I’ll be looking for your rebuttals when my theor arrives today or tomorrow…
;]

]]> By: imisscharlie http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/05/jacob-and-his-nemesis-all-you-need-to-know/#comment-17447 imisscharlie Mon, 01 Jun 2009 23:49:59 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=5591#comment-17447 Absolutely great theory!! You have really taken a 5-season view of the meaning of Lost, and not gotten totally bogged down in minutiae! One of my favorite parts is that you state that Locke is NOT special, not a leader, and the ultimate pawn. I totally agree with this--he has been used and abused throughout the entire series, and not many people see this. (Check out "On Lost: Reflections, Revelations, and Speculations after 5 seasons" in theories for more on who the real hero/leader is.) Also, love your focus on redemption--the writers/producers have always said that this was the major theme, and the time travel is (to me) merely a plot device. Please keep your ideas coming! Absolutely great theory!! You have really taken a 5-season view of the meaning of Lost, and not gotten totally bogged down in minutiae! One of my favorite parts is that you state that Locke is NOT special, not a leader, and the ultimate pawn. I totally agree with this–he has been used and abused throughout the entire series, and not many people see this. (Check out “On Lost: Reflections, Revelations, and Speculations after 5 seasons” in theories for more on who the real hero/leader is.)
Also, love your focus on redemption–the writers/producers have always said that this was the major theme, and the time travel is (to me) merely a plot device.
Please keep your ideas coming!

]]>