Comments on: Falpert: A Solution to Richard Alpert, The Others & The Supposed Lines Of Communication Between Jacob & His ‘Followers’ http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/07/falpert-a-solution-to-richard-alpert-the-others-the-supposed-lines-of-communication-between-jacob-his-followers/ A place to write and read Lost Theories Thu, 09 Feb 2012 14:45:23 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.5 By: ekolocation http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/07/falpert-a-solution-to-richard-alpert-the-others-the-supposed-lines-of-communication-between-jacob-his-followers/#comment-19886 ekolocation Tue, 10 Nov 2009 14:33:58 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=6911#comment-19886 great theory. well thought out. although personally i think you are assuming too much good on jacobs side without enough evidence. We only hear one conversation way out of context, and really either side could be the bad one. otherwise sounds pretty solid. however i think if richard is in on it... i dont think he is a reanimated body. he is around too often for that. great theory. well thought out. although personally i think you are assuming too much good on jacobs side without enough evidence. We only hear one conversation way out of context, and really either side could be the bad one.

otherwise sounds pretty solid. however i think if richard is in on it… i dont think he is a reanimated body. he is around too often for that.

(Report comment)

]]> By: Angus http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/07/falpert-a-solution-to-richard-alpert-the-others-the-supposed-lines-of-communication-between-jacob-his-followers/#comment-19867 Angus Wed, 29 Jul 2009 03:09:51 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=6911#comment-19867 Good stuff risebysin. Some things that I am not clear on though. You are saying that Flocke and Alpert are one and the same? Also I'm not sure that Jacob wouldn't allow the purge or somehow set up the bus hitting Juliettes' ex. We saw him letting the car hit Nadia when he could have saved her. Morals the way we think of them don't seem to apply to Jacob if they get in the way of his agenda. Where Ben fell and was confronted by the Smoke Monster and his daughter is not the temple. We still haven't seen that yet and I am very interested in what is in there! There are definitely different factions working together toward different agendas but knowing who's who and what team they are on is all up in the air. Good stuff risebysin. Some things that I am not clear on though. You are saying that Flocke and Alpert are one and the same? Also I’m not sure that Jacob wouldn’t allow the purge or somehow set up the bus hitting Juliettes’ ex. We saw him letting the car hit Nadia when he could have saved her. Morals the way we think of them don’t seem to apply to Jacob if they get in the way of his agenda.

Where Ben fell and was confronted by the Smoke Monster and his daughter is not the temple. We still haven’t seen that yet and I am very interested in what is in there!

There are definitely different factions working together toward different agendas but knowing who’s who and what team they are on is all up in the air.

(Report comment)

]]> By: dabiatchishere http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2009/07/falpert-a-solution-to-richard-alpert-the-others-the-supposed-lines-of-communication-between-jacob-his-followers/#comment-19866 dabiatchishere Wed, 29 Jul 2009 02:37:43 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=6911#comment-19866 risebysin, I just want to say first off, really nice work! This is an awesome theory! I also think you have hit on some significant things. Mainly, Richard Alpert, and Ben being a pawn along with Locke in addition! I do have a few questions, that I would like you to answer. Why do you think Ilana asks for Richard upon her arrival at the statue? Jacob recruits her assistance, so I am curious to know why she specifically asks for him. You haven't actually stated such, but I think you are implying that Jacob's Nemesis could be a fallen angel. Is this accurate? I like this idea, as it would give meaning to the nature of Jacob and his Nemesis' dispute and relationship. Also, where and what team do you think Christian Shephard is playing for/on? I think you have tied things together quite nicely. The only thing I am uncertain of, and it is not because you haven't done a wonderful job at illustrating and presenting your case is, about the smoke monster. I'll have to do more thinking on this aspect. I will definitely come back with more thoughts, when you have time to answer the above. I have more input for you. Again, splendid job! risebysin, I just want to say first off, really nice work! This is an awesome theory!

I also think you have hit on some significant things. Mainly, Richard Alpert, and Ben being a pawn along with Locke in addition!

I do have a few questions, that I would like you to answer. Why do you think Ilana asks for Richard upon her arrival at the statue? Jacob recruits her assistance, so I am curious to know why she specifically asks for him.

You haven’t actually stated such, but I think you are implying that Jacob’s Nemesis could be a fallen angel. Is this accurate? I like this idea, as it would give meaning to the nature of Jacob and his Nemesis’ dispute and relationship.

Also, where and what team do you think Christian Shephard is playing for/on?

I think you have tied things together quite nicely. The only thing I am uncertain of, and it is not because you haven’t done a wonderful job at illustrating and presenting your case is, about the smoke monster. I’ll have to do more thinking on this aspect.

I will definitely come back with more thoughts, when you have time to answer the above. I have more input for you.

Again, splendid job!

(Report comment)

]]>