Comments on: Simple as “Black & White”

By: waycurious

waycurious — Fri, 11 Dec 2009 14:53:37 +0000

Not sure they’re feuding. Consider Jacob/MIB’s discussion is really …

“There is no replacement.”

“I can’t give up.”

“I’d really like to help you out, bro.”

“I know.”

By: Joshcgs

Joshcgs — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 12:04:32 +0000

Chief – I know I kind of contradict myself in the theory a little bit but it is only because I am really not sure.

I say Jacob touched them all (O6) so that this time everything could play out different. He could probably transport them all to the present at that moment he said “they’re coming”

But I also say that FLocke gave the original order to bring everyone back, so how much of a threat to him could they be.

UNLESS – he does not know about Jacob’s personal visits!!!

Either way – when THEY do come, he is going to pretend to be Locke and Sun is going to expose him.

By: Dharma_Man

Dharma_Man — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:02:24 +0000

Im just a bit worried that whatever happens, no matter what theory anyone throws out there, it is all going to end with Jack waking up on the beach as he did in the pilot episode! If it does happen then im going to be so so so disappointed with the writers, i really can see it happeningthough! Creating the loop illusion that no matter what you do on the island, no matter how hard you try to change the fate of the island, it will all end up back at the start. You cant mess with TIME, it will find a way to correct itself, it will always find a way to reset, time is endless and that is what theory the writers will stick with

By: Chiefof16

Chiefof16 — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 02:27:16 +0000

I basically completely agree with this theory, I wrote a similar one recently (I’m so sick of hearing that from other people, then I say it to you, sorry about that) Anyway, I think Flocke has good intentions, and Jacob bad. Therefore, when Jacob says “they’re coming” regardless of who it is that he’s refering to, they’re probably not coming to do a whole lot of good to the island, and I think whoever it is, Jacob made it happen. In other words, I think that when Jacob died, something on the island changed in Flocke’s favor. Possibly peace on the island (whatever that means) or the end of the time loop, all good things though. The show could have ended there. HOWEVER, when he says “they’re coming”, we are potentially talking about some pretty wicked people. There needs to be some “evil” or major problems occuring in this last season, to give the viewers something GOOD to hope for on a weekly basis. Whoever is coming will be on a rampage of disaster, it might be some subtle things just to keep the loop going, but it would all be in Jacob’s favor, which means, it wont be in our beloved Losties favor. Well written theory though

By: Joshcgs

Joshcgs — Sun, 26 Jul 2009 14:57:07 +0000

FLocke or Esau, whatever you want to call him was probably living on that island just fine – no evil plans to take over the world.

We all saw how he only came to see Jacob because of the ship. Jacob offered him food, said please sit, they have obviously known eachother for a long time.

I do not think he hates Jacob or wants Jacob off the island. He hates what Jacob is doing

“I don’t have to ask. You brought them here. Still trying to prove me wrong, aren’t you?”

Jacob keeps this game going and going just to prove a point!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By: Joshcgs

Joshcgs — Sun, 26 Jul 2009 14:52:14 +0000

the one in all caps?

I see what you’re saying, that Jacob and his brother (Esau) have been feuding whether mankind can be civilized, and one is just trying to prove the other wrong. The game has been going on for so long that Esau is just pissed off and wants to kill Jacob, but for some reason needs a 3rd party to do so. Probably because the two are linked and and one can not destroy the other.

This being said, its a good theory, but I do not like the idea that they are pulling all strings.

I think Jacob is sitting back and watching, hoping we make the right choices – like life is a game to him. And everytime we screw up he tries again, but does something different each time. This time he made first contact with all the O6 (NOT EVEYONE -ONLY THOSE WHO LEFT, AND HE DID SO BEFORE THEY LEFT, not hurley and sayid) to create a connection between them. This connection is describe in my theory above.

I beleive who you this is Esau, is sick of allowing Jacob play this game. He hates the fact that Jacob brings US to his island. and the only way to stop Jacob from doing so is so kill him!

By: jschorrii

jschorrii — Sun, 26 Jul 2009 14:19:41 +0000

check out my latest theory and tell me what you think about yours after that