Welcome to Theories On Lost.
Theories on Lost is a Lost Theory website for users to submit their own Lost Theories or to read other Lost Theories. There are plenty of Lost Theories to get stuck into so be sure to add us to your favourites!
Theories on Lost is a Lost Theory website for users to submit their own Lost Theories or to read other Lost Theories. There are plenty of Lost Theories to get stuck into so be sure to add us to your favourites!
Timeline
Sept. 22, 2004 +101 days=January 02, 2005 + the time they faked getting to another island and being rescued from it.
If they are off the island for three years, then shouldn’t flight 316 have taken place in 2008?
Or is it because of the special island properties that the dates don’t add up
RECEIVE THE LATEST THEORIES IN YOUR INBOX!To receive the latest Lost Theories straight to your inbox click here.
Alternatively, sign up using a RSS reader by clicking here.
37 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Leave a comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Login
About cocoadoll:
Hi. I am an uber Lost fan. Admittedly, I jumped on the bandwagon a little late, halfway through the third season but thanks to the DVD's I am all caught up and do frequent re-watches. BTW my new image reflects my love/hate relationship with Lost. I always feel like I am on the verge of blowing up at the end of every episode because when I think I finally figured it out, nope the rug is pulled out.
Post count: 54 | Comment count: 81
@15:26:46
…..what?
(Report comment)
@15:30:51
LMAO…ummm…I think the confusion sets in when people take the “three years later” thing a little too literally.
(Report comment)
@15:44:06
clearly they need a disclaimer of some sort now…..
“This television show is not broadcast in real time. Thank you.”
(Report comment)
@15:48:39
Ha, they should have added that onto the end of the clip on “The Onion”
(Report comment)
@15:59:17
“Pams having Jims baby next episode, but like, how is that possible…she’s only been pregnant for what, 12 days?”
(Report comment)
@16:02:36
Is Pam really having the baby next episode Bailey…….?
(Report comment)
@16:04:40
no she’s having it on the Feb 4th episode i believe, and it’ll be 2 back to back half hour episodes
Can’t freakin wait!
(Report comment)
@16:05:33
LMAO….. We’re totally just tearing up Cocoadoll’s question.
(Report comment)
@16:08:42
It is mostly derived from the 3 years later and 30 years later stuff. Sawyer and company flashed to 1974. That has been given. Then the text says 3 years later, so that must be 1977, and I think that is also stated. Then they flash 30 years later, so that must be 2007. either way there is no time thing going on.
(Report comment)
@16:08:43
we really are. I almost deleted my post because i’m starting to feel horrible about my comment….
I really do enjoy your other posts cocoadoll! This one just caught me off guard and i got all sarcastic ‘n crap before i could stop myself
(Report comment)
@16:09:15
Oh god…ummm…move to my “Are you serious” post in fun…its junk anyway and can be “tore up”…I gotta know about this….
(Report comment)
@16:13:13
Sorry cocoa, committing a pet peeve of mine here…
(Report comment)
@16:27:39
No, what I meant is why did the rest of flight 316 flash back to 2007 when the flight was in January of 2008 (courtesy of Lostpedia).
(Report comment)
@16:30:48
PS: I hate the US version of the Office, but I heart Ricky Gervais and the original version.
(Report comment)
@16:37:07
I catch your drift…even Lostpedia…uncanon btw, lol, has it listed at 2008 as well…it got brought up last year and forgot…I couldnt see how it could be anything to do with the story…but its possible. Maybe a mistake on the writers part. Most of the island time was in december…I truly wasnt aware of the date in terms of what month they were rescued.
It could very well have something to do with the lie.
They were ANNOUNCED possibly as rescued then…but wasnt it still December when the island disappeared…maybe thats the “3year” difference…
OH…5 stars for asking a good question…minus 4 and a half for not liking the American Office
;]
(Report comment)
@18:36:13
It was December 24th , 2004 when Desmond talked to Penny on the phone. I’m not sure how many days followed in season 4.
(Report comment)
@13:41:20
ok people, here it is:
September 22nd, 2004 is the crash date.
September has 9 days left in it.
October has 31 days
November has 30 days
December has 31 days
9+31+30+31=101
101 days after the crash was December 31st, 2004.
Nothiggn to see here folks, move it along.
(Report comment)
@14:53:58
Umm… I think they were rescued 108 days after the crash. So it would make it January
(Report comment)
@15:13:54
it would…but since it was 101 days it remains Dec. 31st
(Report comment)
@02:45:35
It was 108 days, I remember that because 108 is the same number as how many minutes between button pushes at The Hatch.
I just checked Lostpedia and it says they were rescued 108 days later, on January 7th, 2005.
(Report comment)
@05:15:59
True, Lostpedia isn’t canon but that doesn’t mean that the stuff you read there isn’t canon. It’s just stuff that Lostpedia says that isn’t specifically from the show (like the theories) that isn’t canon.
(Report comment)
@05:30:48
Sorry, don’t mean to sidetrack anyone, but what the hell does “canon” mean? Is it like credibility? I’m anxious to learn all your ultra mega-cool theorist lingo here.
(Report comment)
@05:32:26
Things that are canon are definitely part of the show/story. Things that aren’t canon are not actually included in the story… like fan fiction and some of the comic-con stuff…
(Report comment)
@05:48:35
That answered it well, thanks
(Report comment)
@08:41:44
They left the island on day 101.
They were fake “rescued” on day 108.
The island flashed (which is what we’re are talking about here, we’re talking about when the island flashed) on day 101. Which was on December 31st. Which was still in 2004…i’m just getting this from Lostpedia aswell, i’m not sure why i’m the only one who knows this, it’s right there on the page….lol
(Report comment)
@12:07:35
I thought the whole point of this post was asking why it’s 2007 and not 2008 on island where Sun and co. are.
Even if it was December 31st 2004 when the island flashed, it’ll be January 1st 2005 the day after.
We don’t even know if it’s exactly 3 years. It didn’t look Christmassy when they took Flight 316.
(Report comment)
@12:13:23
The date of the flight was 21st January 2008 - so 3 years and a few weeks.
(Report comment)
@12:26:50
Yes. I also thought that the post was asking why they had landed in 2007 and not 2008….and my answer remains the same: because the day the island started to flash through time was December 31st 2007. 2007. not 2008. and so they flashed back to 2007. If we want to get all Lostpedia technicalish they flashed back to July 22nd, 2007. Which makes even less sense.
(Report comment)
@12:27:14
(Report comment)
@12:58:35
I thought the day the island started flashing through time was December 2004? Not 2007?
Now I’m even more confused.
(Report comment)
@13:20:09
sorry i meant “because the day the island started to flash through time was December 31st 2004. 2004. not 2005. and so they flashed back to 2007.”
i’m regretting commenting on this theory immediatly.
(Report comment)
@13:20:17
Where did the July 22, 2007 date come from? I didn’t see that date referenced in the Lostpedia article for the episode 316 or the article for Ajira Flight 316. I don’t remember hearing anyone on the show actually say “wow, this is what the island looks like in 2007″… I think the year was just speculation and that it was actually January 2008… The time on the island is December 2004 + however much time they spent off-island (around three years). The same time period (around three years) also corresponds to the amount of time between 1974 (when Sawyer and crew stopped flashing) and the appearance of Jack, Kate, etc…
Right?
(Report comment)
@13:25:56
The new iPad looks worthless. Thanks Apple.
(Report comment)
@13:38:13
Highbrow: i can’t remember where i read that LOL it was definitly somewhere on Lostpedia cause i don’t bother looking anywhere else. But i tried to go back to the timeline page i was looking at, and i can’t find it….If i remember it was some “could be true/could not be true/picked up by some old newspaper heading in the background” type thing. and i hate this thread to much to continue looking.
(Report comment)
@13:46:05
trinity: the question was this: “why did the rest of flight 316 flash back to 2007 when the flight was in January of 2008 (courtesy of Lostpedia).”
and my answer is this “because the island started skipping through time in 2004. and they were taken back to 3 years after they left the island. 2007.”
i could be wrong. but thats my answer.
(Report comment)
@13:51:13
Until I see something that says 2007 outside of a theory page (which is where the 2007 date originated… I’m pretty sure) I’m going to say that the plane crashed on January 22nd, 2008. Any other date would be completely arbitrary.
It really isn’t important anyway, is it?
(Report comment)
@15:33:59
It sure isnt’ highbrow. considering Lostpedia says:
A) The plane crash-landed on Hydra Island in 2007.
B) Ajira Airways Flight 316 experiences a flash of light in the middle of the night in January of 2008
C) In 2007, Ajira Airways Flight 316 departed from LAX in Los Angeles, California bound for Guam
I’d say hell no it isn’t important lol
(Report comment)