IMO it has been one of those things like the smoke monster & the statue that was introduced as a mystery early on.

We have been given more information about the smoke monster and statue everytime we see it, but the cabin is just more questions.

Thanks for your input BiNG, always appreciated!

(Report comment)

I am now sure that Jacob had to leave his knife & his cut piece of Tapestry at some point in time, IDK when but it had to be Jacob because Richard knew where Jacob was & he seemed kind of confused & unaware of Llana being there at all so why would Richard leave a clue? Unless Richard did it under order of Jacob.

Ill help you try & figure this out Josh, maybe a question at a time but its something.

(Report comment)

The cabin is of some interest to me as well Josh but I think your a lil obsessed with this damned cabin, You raised some good questions though.

I believe that at one point Jacob used the cabin for himself, I dont know if thats before or after the Ash was put around the cabin. Why do you think Llana & Jacobs guardian’s go to the cabin first to most likely meet up with Jacob? An how did they know where to go, hmmm???

I thought Hurley is the reason the Ash circle was broken & that is how it moves but when I was looking on lostpedia I found out that when Hurley first seen the cabin it seemed to have moved from when John first went with Ben.

A way of knowing that would be when John is taking the group to the Cabin (Not with just Hurley & Ben) Hurley thinks they might be going the wrong way & John only knew one way there but doesnt find it, he does find the circle ring but no cabin.

So maybe Hurley didnt break the ash circle after all, if it moved before he even walked up to it is the proof but what if John or Ben did while rushing out the cabin the first time?

That would explain why it is able to move so Hurley finds it but that really isnt that relevant who broke the ash.

(Report comment)

(Report comment)