Comments on: Great episode! No, bad episode. Wait, what? http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/great-episode-no-bad-episode-wait-what/ A place to write and read Lost Theories Thu, 09 Feb 2012 12:59:00 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.5 By: Chiefof16 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/great-episode-no-bad-episode-wait-what/#comment-34177 Chiefof16 Sun, 16 May 2010 19:49:16 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13512#comment-34177 I really don't recall seeing any Dharma clothes on them. If they were dressed that way, wouldn't there have been a ton of theories about Adam and Eve being some specific Dharma folks instead of Rose and Bernard? Anyway, I'm a firm believer that the ghost of Claudia was NOT Claudia. I'm going to once again embarrass myself here, and somehow piss some people off in the process.....I think it was indeed the smoke monster. Wouldn't Claudia's real ghost say something like, "I love you guys" or "How's Jacob's rash doing?" or "I'm so sorry I can't be with you."? Claudia seemed creepy to me, and I still believe the sole reason for her showing up to MIB was to put some temptation in his heart. I know now that it's ridiculously ubsurd to think that Smokie existed before MIB headed towards the light, but I'm sticking with it like I'm sticking with Jacob having bad intentions. I really don’t recall seeing any Dharma clothes on them. If they were dressed that way, wouldn’t there have been a ton of theories about Adam and Eve being some specific Dharma folks instead of Rose and Bernard?

Anyway, I’m a firm believer that the ghost of Claudia was NOT Claudia. I’m going to once again embarrass myself here, and somehow piss some people off in the process…..I think it was indeed the smoke monster.

Wouldn’t Claudia’s real ghost say something like, “I love you guys” or “How’s Jacob’s rash doing?” or “I’m so sorry I can’t be with you.”? Claudia seemed creepy to me, and I still believe the sole reason for her showing up to MIB was to put some temptation in his heart.

I know now that it’s ridiculously ubsurd to think that Smokie existed before MIB headed towards the light, but I’m sticking with it like I’m sticking with Jacob having bad intentions.

(Report comment)

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/great-episode-no-bad-episode-wait-what/#comment-34172 A.E.S. Sun, 16 May 2010 17:13:19 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13512#comment-34172 I actually thought they had the DI gear on too...half the reason I thought it would be someone we know....guess I was wrong too. trinity...good to see you, good point about DI not being introduced until second season. I actually thought they had the DI gear on too…half the reason I thought it would be someone we know….guess I was wrong too.

trinity…good to see you, good point about DI not being introduced until second season.

(Report comment)

]]> By: trinity http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/great-episode-no-bad-episode-wait-what/#comment-34168 trinity Sun, 16 May 2010 13:46:21 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13512#comment-34168 These are just my own personal thoughts on what happened in this episode. 1. I think when Jacobs brother went into the light, it created the Smoke Monster. I've always thought the writers would show us how the Smoke Monster came to be, and if this isn't it then they're going to have to find a way to fit it in in the next 3 episodes (not likely). I think there was something in the light that merged with Jacobs brother which created Smokey. Even though Jacob found his brothers dead body, his brothers soul was now in Smokey. 2. I think their real mother was one of those who had trouble passing on, and Jacobs brother had a gift similar to Hurley that allowed him to see dead people. Afterall, if it had been smokey, wouldn't Jacob have seen her aswell? 3. I don't think they were found wearing Dharma uniforms. I think we were only introduced to Dharma in Season 2. These are just my own personal thoughts on what happened in this episode.

1. I think when Jacobs brother went into the light, it created the Smoke Monster. I’ve always thought the writers would show us how the Smoke Monster came to be, and if this isn’t it then they’re going to have to find a way to fit it in in the next 3 episodes (not likely). I think there was something in the light that merged with Jacobs brother which created Smokey. Even though Jacob found his brothers dead body, his brothers soul was now in Smokey.

2. I think their real mother was one of those who had trouble passing on, and Jacobs brother had a gift similar to Hurley that allowed him to see dead people. Afterall, if it had been smokey, wouldn’t Jacob have seen her aswell?

3. I don’t think they were found wearing Dharma uniforms. I think we were only introduced to Dharma in Season 2.

(Report comment)

]]> By: Andre7 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/great-episode-no-bad-episode-wait-what/#comment-34165 Andre7 Sun, 16 May 2010 12:39:04 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13512#comment-34165 Were they wearing Dharma coveralls? I thought so but was not sure. Have to watch the episode again. If so, it shows that the writers are not paying attention to details the way fans do. Also shows that they are making it up as they go and changing a lot of the original plans they may or may not have made from the start. Personally I think their whole "We do not want to explain everything to preserve the essence of the mystery of Lost" is a cop out so they will not have to admit any mistakes or or changes they brought "en route"... Were they wearing Dharma coveralls? I thought so but was not sure. Have to watch the episode again.

If so, it shows that the writers are not paying attention to details the way fans do. Also shows that they are making it up as they go and changing a lot of the original plans they may or may not have made from the start.

Personally I think their whole “We do not want to explain everything to preserve the essence of the mystery of Lost” is a cop out so they will not have to admit any mistakes or or changes they brought “en route”…

(Report comment)

]]>