Comments on: My last theory cos it’s the End of an Era http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/ A place to write and read Lost Theories Thu, 17 May 2012 19:43:17 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: DeadPakistaniOnYourCouch http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/#comment-34320 DeadPakistaniOnYourCouch Tue, 18 May 2010 16:35:22 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13591#comment-34320 This was a great read! I still think Locke will come back somehow and become the protector of the island. His body is still buried on the island and as it was said "nothing on this island stays buried for long". I was thinking that the reason Locke was able to walk from the crash was because Jack will fix Locke's spine in tonight's episode (Maybe Sunday) and that will also affect MIB in the other timeline This was a great read! I still think Locke will come back somehow and become the protector of the island. His body is still buried on the island and as it was said
“nothing on this island stays buried for long”. I was thinking that the reason Locke was able to walk from the crash was because Jack will fix Locke’s spine in tonight’s episode (Maybe Sunday) and that will also affect MIB in the other timeline

]]> By: highbrow http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/#comment-34311 highbrow Tue, 18 May 2010 14:41:46 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13591#comment-34311 I'm the nice one, right? Right? Seriously, I love this show and this site has been awesome... I love the discussion, even with the people I don't agree with... AES and I would agree more if he didn't post drunk so often. I saw right through his ‘Amy’ post for the bait that it was... I kid, really. There's a lot of stuff in this theory! The pregnancy issue, I think, is definitely related to the Swan Station. Maybe related to jughead or maybe not. I think the station and the button pressing might be disrupting the light or access to the light... something like that. I like Vincent too and I'm kinda pissed that we haven't seen him in a while... I hope we see him again... I think we will. Aaron seems like the character they had plans for then dropped, and that worries me. They won't do that, will they? I think (hope) that Aaron will be back in the story tonight, or at the very least on Sunday. If Jack isn't the candidate (I think he is) then I think it's Aaron and I think it'll be Jack who raises him on the island to become the protector. Walt is special but I think they brought Desmond in to fill that role on the island... maybe he'll be back, maybe not. Who knows? I doubt the Hurley Bird will ever be revisited. I think it was the smoke monster though. I’m the nice one, right?

Right?

Seriously, I love this show and this site has been awesome… I love the discussion, even with the people I don’t agree with… AES and I would agree more if he didn’t post drunk so often. I saw right through his ‘Amy’ post for the bait that it was…

I kid, really.

There’s a lot of stuff in this theory!

The pregnancy issue, I think, is definitely related to the Swan Station. Maybe related to jughead or maybe not. I think the station and the button pressing might be disrupting the light or access to the light… something like that.

I like Vincent too and I’m kinda pissed that we haven’t seen him in a while… I hope we see him again… I think we will.

Aaron seems like the character they had plans for then dropped, and that worries me. They won’t do that, will they? I think (hope) that Aaron will be back in the story tonight, or at the very least on Sunday. If Jack isn’t the candidate (I think he is) then I think it’s Aaron and I think it’ll be Jack who raises him on the island to become the protector.

Walt is special but I think they brought Desmond in to fill that role on the island… maybe he’ll be back, maybe not. Who knows?

I doubt the Hurley Bird will ever be revisited. I think it was the smoke monster though.

]]> By: greatforsaken http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/#comment-34292 greatforsaken Tue, 18 May 2010 05:28:07 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13591#comment-34292 I think in order for someone to end up as "THE" candidate, they will have to step and take the job. I cant see Hurley stepping up and deciding to be the one. Ive ALWAYS wanted Hurley to be a big hero at the end, and when the question was posed, "what lies in the shadow of the statue?" and was answered with "He who will save us all" I hoped to god that it turned out to be Hurley. He has always been the purest soul, the kindest and most caring person on the show. But never sure in himself and always a secondary character outside of Locke/Jack Sawyer/Kate earlier on. Kate I think is still in the running regardless of being crossed off. But would she want the job? I cant see any reason why she would. Sawyer could very well be redeemed by stepping up and saying he wants to finally take responsibilty and becoming the new protector. Would his off island daughter influence his decision though? Jack we all know already thinks he is meant for the job and wouldnt hesitate. But the one everyone wants to see get the job.....the one some people including myself thought would never be in the position to get the job, is Locke. He IS dead, and peoples logic was that he would have his mind travel from the FSW somehow and would be back on the island. Or something like that anyways. I never bought it. BUT! The light on the island is Life.....Death....and Rebirth..... What if they threw Locke's body into the Waterfall of Light? Yes, very morbid, but I think it would be great. Bottom line is though, I think if there is a protector chosen, it wont last long, and I think that new Jacob will use some trick to sink the island. Maybe even having to die to do so. I think in order for someone to end up as “THE” candidate, they will have to step and take the job. I cant see Hurley stepping up and deciding to be the one. Ive ALWAYS wanted Hurley to be a big hero at the end, and when the question was posed, “what lies in the shadow of the statue?” and was answered with “He who will save us all” I hoped to god that it turned out to be Hurley. He has always been the purest soul, the kindest and most caring person on the show. But never sure in himself and always a secondary character outside of Locke/Jack Sawyer/Kate earlier on.

Kate I think is still in the running regardless of being crossed off. But would she want the job? I cant see any reason why she would.

Sawyer could very well be redeemed by stepping up and saying he wants to finally take responsibilty and becoming the new protector. Would his off island daughter influence his decision though?

Jack we all know already thinks he is meant for the job and wouldnt hesitate.

But the one everyone wants to see get the job…..the one some people including myself thought would never be in the position to get the job, is Locke. He IS dead, and peoples logic was that he would have his mind travel from the FSW somehow and would be back on the island. Or something like that anyways. I never bought it. BUT! The light on the island is Life…..Death….and Rebirth….. What if they threw Locke’s body into the Waterfall of Light? Yes, very morbid, but I think it would be great.

Bottom line is though, I think if there is a protector chosen, it wont last long, and I think that new Jacob will use some trick to sink the island. Maybe even having to die to do so.

]]> By: A.E.S. http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/#comment-34287 A.E.S. Tue, 18 May 2010 05:07:38 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13591#comment-34287 Steph...I feel your pain. Dont get me all teared up now...do you know how big the tears are that come out of this thing? Great final theory. I cant agree more about Jack NOT being the candidate. I really think he is not supposed to be. All of the people you named have great potential...but I still hope it is Locke in the long run. I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY hope and think that we will get some answer for Walt by the end...even if its just a cheesy "flashback" like we saw with the stones... I ALWAYS thought the last thing we see on Lost would be Vincent standing alone on the island...I thought it would be a wonderful way to end the show...and regardless of what happened to ANYONE else...we woul be able to sit back and say "Awww...Vincent is OK." I think the prego issues will be covered by Jugghead...but it may have been neccesary to stop the island from sinking...if Jugghead did NOT sink the island, but neutralize the energy and keep it afloat. Just posted something about Widmore in "Questions"...I feel the same way. I NEED to know what happens to Rose and Bernard on island. I can assume the worst, but maybe their good nature, and "none of my beezwax" mentality will save them in the end. I think Kate is the wildcard...she is the one who may ultimately save them in the end. I cant help but think of her playing a role much like "mother"...she raised anothers kid, and with all the "Joan Hart" alias this year, she could very well have some magical tricks up her sleeve... She is a great mystery for me, and I really am excited to know her role. Aaron...Aaron, Aaron, Aaron...yes...we NEED answers. Someone recently suggested a portal of sorts for MIB...I think its quite possible. I cant help but think about when they first arrived and he stopped kicking. And how he started kicking again when she ate the fish from the ocean. I also think about Claires dream in the first season. the one where Locke tells her she shouldnt have given away, while the crib is filled with blood. I also cant help but think that may have been MIB connecting through her sub-conscious from another life or time... Highbrow pops in every now and then...I was hoping to get his attention with my recent "Amy" post...practically the reason I wrote it...feeling nostalgic... I guess I wouldnt comment either if I knew I was wrong... ;] I also wish "Paula" was here more...I really do...I miss here quite a bit... Now am I the smart/wise guy...or the angry hateful guy?...no...no...dont answer that...it wouldnt be very nice... ;] Ill miss you Steph...I really will. I always appreciated you comments and theories...and damn if you didnt make this one your best! I have to tell you...now dont cry... But I wear a Scotland shirt sometimes to watch Lost (now before you make fun of me...how much time do you spend on LOST?), and have always said its for Desmond Hume ...from now on it will be for you... I said DONT cry... Ok...now go ahead and tell which is the hateful one and which is the knowledgeable one... Great theory, and although I WANT and NEED the end to come on LOST...even if it only happens once... I hate that THIS will end. :[ Steph…I feel your pain.
Dont get me all teared up now…do you know how big the tears are that come out of this thing?

Great final theory.

I cant agree more about Jack NOT being the candidate.
I really think he is not supposed to be. All of the people you named have great potential…but I still hope it is Locke in the long run.

I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY hope and think that we will get some answer for Walt by the end…even if its just a cheesy “flashback” like we saw with the stones…

I ALWAYS thought the last thing we see on Lost would be Vincent standing alone on the island…I thought it would be a wonderful way to end the show…and regardless of what happened to ANYONE else…we woul be able to sit back and say “Awww…Vincent is OK.”

I think the prego issues will be covered by Jugghead…but it may have been neccesary to stop the island from sinking…if Jugghead did NOT sink the island, but neutralize the energy and keep it afloat.

Just posted something about Widmore in “Questions”…I feel the same way.

I NEED to know what happens to Rose and Bernard on island.
I can assume the worst, but maybe their good nature, and “none of my beezwax” mentality will save them in the end.

I think Kate is the wildcard…she is the one who may ultimately save them in the end.
I cant help but think of her playing a role much like “mother”…she raised anothers kid, and with all the “Joan Hart” alias this year, she could very well have some magical tricks up her sleeve…
She is a great mystery for me, and I really am excited to know her role.

Aaron…Aaron, Aaron, Aaron…yes…we NEED answers.

Someone recently suggested a portal of sorts for MIB…I think its quite possible.

I cant help but think about when they first arrived and he stopped kicking. And how he started kicking again when she ate the fish from the ocean.
I also think about Claires dream in the first season. the one where Locke tells her she shouldnt have given away, while the crib is filled with blood.
I also cant help but think that may have been MIB connecting through her sub-conscious from another life or time…

Highbrow pops in every now and then…I was hoping to get his attention with my recent “Amy” post…practically the reason I wrote it…feeling nostalgic…

I guess I wouldnt comment either if I knew I was wrong…
;]

I also wish “Paula” was here more…I really do…I miss here quite a bit…

Now am I the smart/wise guy…or the angry hateful guy?…no…no…dont answer that…it wouldnt be very nice…
;]

Ill miss you Steph…I really will. I always appreciated you comments and theories…and damn if you didnt make this one your best!

I have to tell you…now dont cry…

But I wear a Scotland shirt sometimes to watch Lost (now before you make fun of me…how much time do you spend on LOST?), and have always said its for Desmond Hume
…from now on it will be for you…

I said DONT cry…
Ok…now go ahead and tell which is the hateful one and which is the knowledgeable one…

Great theory, and although I WANT and NEED the end to come on LOST…even if it only happens once…
I hate that THIS will end.
:[

]]> By: Clairespeanutbutter http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/#comment-34278 Clairespeanutbutter Tue, 18 May 2010 03:35:38 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13591#comment-34278 Nice post - very touching. I'm not ready to think about letting go just yet... As far as the questions you pose - all very good. I'll be quite pleased if we get at least half of the questions you posted answered... and we can continue to debate about the rest... Nice post – very touching. I’m not ready to think about letting go just yet…

As far as the questions you pose – all very good. I’ll be quite pleased if we get at least half of the questions you posted answered… and we can continue to debate about the rest…

]]> By: cocoadoll http://www.theoriesonlost.com/2010/05/my-last-theory-cos-its-the-end-of-an-era/#comment-34262 cocoadoll Tue, 18 May 2010 01:23:07 +0000 http://www.theoriesonlost.com/?p=13591#comment-34262 You can never be sure about anything on Lost, epsecially candidates but c'mon from day one (well, after Michael Keaton got scratched out and they rebooted) Jack has been the man (much to a lot of people's dismay, I really wanted it to be Locke)to which has been singled out and chosen to lead and fix things along the way. This season hasn't been about twists and turns, its been pretty straight forward, so dont, unless you want to be disappointed, dont expect any huge last minute twists, the story is coming to an end, there is no more time, nor a need for suspense, as the promos have said this season, the time for answers is now, even if they are trite, contrary and spoon fed to us, and really just baby bird food that was made from recycled theories that they found on sites much like this one. Happy Lost Finale Week. You can never be sure about anything on Lost, epsecially candidates but c’mon from day one (well, after Michael Keaton got scratched out and they rebooted) Jack has been the man (much to a lot of people’s dismay, I really wanted it to be Locke)to which has been singled out and chosen to lead and fix things along the way. This season hasn’t been about twists and turns, its been pretty straight forward, so dont, unless you want to be disappointed, dont expect any huge last minute twists, the story is coming to an end, there is no more time, nor a need for suspense, as the promos have said this season, the time for answers is now, even if they are trite, contrary and spoon fed to us, and really just baby bird food that was made from recycled theories that they found on sites much like this one. Happy Lost Finale Week.

]]>