Smoke Monster = Judgement *SPOILER ALERT*

*********CAUTION-SPOILER ALERT***********

Hey, whoever thought the Smoke Monster was a way to judge a man’s soul was right….

In the upcoming episode 5.12 ‘ ‘Dead is Dead’


To atone for sins of the past, Ben must attempt to summon the smoke monster in order to be judged.

Share with fellow Losties

Written by


I am an disgruntled fan of Lost. I love to hate it and hate it to love it. JJ is notorious for letting down fans but I don't hold it against Lost. I have a crazy theory that has been brewing for the last year now and I will be posting it shortly. Forgive my tirades and bitter comments. I get on edge when I can't get my Lost fix.

4 thoughts on “Smoke Monster = Judgement *SPOILER ALERT*

  1. This is a straight up spoiler IMO. It seems like your trying to goat people in for your own priorities. I personally like what you contribute around here, plus your ideas are fresh which is comforting, But stunts like this will get you SOMEWHERE?……..IMO

  2. I agree with Smokey, please place spoiler in your title next time, I did not want to know this but the manner in which I read, I had read the whole post before the first line hit my conscious brain.

    On your theory, I do believe and always have since the monster stopped in front of Eko the first time, that this was some avenue for judgment.

  3. So Smokey judges people, but is that it’s purpose? Does it Seth Norris because he is “bad”? Does it kill Eko because of his childhood?

    So Ben can or at least tries to summon the monster, which we saw when it wiped out Keamy’s army. So this means that the purpose for which smokey can be summoned can be decided.

    Everytime we see Smokey, do you think it is summoned, or does it freelance around on its own accord?

    How about the forms it takes? Does Smokey have its own “mind” or is it just a supercomputer that has memory and is commanded to do certain things? While this is a plot spoiler, there is still a lot about Smokey that is a mystery.

    By the way, where do you find all of these spoilers?

Leave a Reply