I would like to bring up something that I found interesting last night. When claire asked Locke if they (candidates) were all dead from the sub crash he replied “Not all of them”. This made me wonder how could MIB know that their wereÂ survivors? He couldn’t see them swim up to the beach.
Another thing that puzzled me was that when Jack pushed MIB into the water their was not some kind of reaction. With all of the rumors going around saying that the devil is “Allergic” to water I thought that I was in for a show. Does anyone have any theories on this?