“You ended up on the wrong side”
I know Dogen eventually told Sayid that MIB/Flocke was evil incarnate but when explaining the torture testing to Sayid, Dogen explained the balance of good and evil and stated the he ended up on the wrong side.  Are the losties being manipulated into believing Jacob is good and Flocke is evil when it is in fact the opposite. It is clear that MIB/Smokey/Flocke killed all of the others who didn’t leave but could those others already be dead already as other posters have alluded to.  Obviously, I am not sure where I stand quite yet but I thought it was curious how it was explained
I totally agree! I wrote a theory involving this (not up yet)…I was thinking that Jacob seems way too manipulative to be as good as everyone (the others) on the island seems to believe! kudos!