Jacob’s Nemesis is not Smoky!
Written on 14th May 2009
At first i thought he was the smoke monster in human form but i am now questioning it and here is why.
when fake locke was walking with Ben on their way to see Jacob and Ben tells him that his dead daughter appeared to him and said that he must do what ever fake locke says he seems surprised. and says well i guess i don’t have to convince you after all. that is screaming at me that they are trying to tell us that the fake locke and smoky are not one in the same. yes it may keep up the illusion he was trying to create that he was the real Locke, but at that point i dont think he cared anymore.
it is obvious to me that smoky and fake locke are working together but i now dont believe that they are one in the same. it also to me explains that jacob’s nemisis can shape shift into people with out needing their bodies (Locke) and smoky needs their bodies (Christian). otherwise it’s just not consistent and it is very unlike the Lost to be
Vicious, I wholeheartedly concur, that Jacob’s nemesis is not the smoke monster!
I had not considered however, that they might be working together!
You make some good points!
here are few points why he is the smoke monster
1. he just happpend to miss ben being judgd.
2. he just happens to show up right after he was judged.
3. Why didn’t the smoke monster come when ben called him. Ill tell you why because he was standing next to ben the whole time
4. the monster doesn’t need the boddies to shape shift he just them needs to be dead.
5. John just happend to be dead at the time
lost4life: then where is Christian’s body? it just isnt consistent.