Questions SHARE: Charlotte’s timeline March 5, 2009 by bo_dough5 I’m new here, and I’ve searched all over and can’t find that this has been discussed yet, so if it has, please forgive me! Anyway, I’m just wondering if anyone else picked up on the discrepancy in Charlotte’s timeline? Share with fellow Losties
bo_dough5, there does seem to be some discrepancy in Charlotte’s time line. If I recall correctly, Ben said Charlotte was born in 1977, so to see her as a young child, would throw that off. Not sure if it was an error, or Ben was wrong/lying. Or, is Dan looking at every little girl with red hair, and thinking it’s Charlotte. Log in to Reply
I don’t think we’ve confirmed the time (late 70s early 80s) of that scene. And yes, Ben is a liar, but even more, in the real world…who knows what time the people that leave the island…actually leave the island in. Log in to Reply
bo_dough5, there does seem to be some discrepancy in Charlotte’s time line.
If I recall correctly, Ben said Charlotte was born in 1977, so to see her as a young child, would throw that off.
Not sure if it was an error, or Ben was wrong/lying. Or, is Dan looking at every little girl with red hair, and thinking it’s Charlotte.
I don’t think we’ve confirmed the time (late 70s early 80s) of that scene. And yes, Ben is a liar, but even more, in the real world…who knows what time the people that leave the island…actually leave the island in.