Smoke Monster is FakeLocke
Written on 16th May 2009
The smokemonster is seemingly all the dead people that we’ve seen on the island. It was Christian and now Locke. It also was Ben’s dead daughter because FakeLocke was not there when we saw Alex. This was because the smokemonster can only imitate one person at a time. It also makes sense that the smoke monster is Jacob’s rival at the beginning, the loophole guy. I think that Jacob is not dead now because Juliet detonating the bomb was not supposed to happen. Jacob is too new and important to be dead.