What really changed?
There is soooooooo much talk about alternate timelines right now…which I dont fully disagree with…but the most prominate defense to this is Dharmaville being different after the Ajira crash.
I have some HUGE problems with this thought.
1)Nothing that we see in the building where Christian Shepard shows Sun the picture is different enough to be concrete evidence.
2)Bens house still stands where it did.
3)ALEXs ROOM is still where Ben remembers it.
4)The monster still knows that Ben killed Alex. (I know that can be argued by simply saying it lives out of time as we know it)
Many of these points still involve the others existing much after the explosion, and Ben still taking Alex just as he did. The others still taking Dharmaville, just a they did.
I dont like the idea of two Lockes beig used as evidence…because there are not two Lockes. There is a Locke and a being posing as Locke.
Most importantly, the small details. Remember when the Losties found the canoe, and Locke, Sawyer, Faraday, Charolette, Miles, and Juliet are having a water shootout?
Well they found an Ajira waterbottle in the boat when they first took it.
Did they “stumble” into an alternate timeline before it happened…no…they went to the future before it happenedfrom their perspective.
I want to believe in the alternate timeline….I just dont believe that is what we are seeing in the 2007 that everyone thinks is alternate.