A possible reason for why Kate is a hobag…
Ok now I’m not really a big believer in the whole ALT timeline idea but I am more than happy to entertain the notion. So just finished season 3 on the rewatch and got thinking about Kate and her not being able to make her mind up between Jack or Sawyer. Now is this maybe something to do with the fact that in one timeline she’s with Jack, one she’s with Sawyer and the timeline we’ve been watching she can’t decide between the two? I dunno about the whole 3 timelines idea but it was just something trinity had said in one of her posts that got me thinking.
I’m still not a big believer in an ALT timeline, I’m not a big believer in WHH either though, then again what I think doesn’t seem to agree with many people out there. Knowing now what the first episode is called makes me think I’m wrong but I’ll believe it when I see it, you know not all is as it seems to be in the World of Lost, the writers will probably hit us with a major curve ball right at the start of season 6.
Anyway, enough jibber jabber from me, let me know what you think…

Is that why she’s with the bank robber and the cop, too? And she was ‘married’ before (probably to Anthony Cooper knowing her).
Surely the bank robber and the cop are irrelevant because they were before the timeline split? Is that not right? I’m assuming that it’s their actions on the island that have caused the split if there is one? I might be totally wrong though…
Hilarious thread title – hilarious ‘about’ section. Can you pass that blunt across the Atlantic?
I like the general idea of this. It got me thinking that maybe in the ALT Jack has a relationship with Juliet, who looks like his ex-wife Sarah, and Ben has a relationship with Sarah, who looks like Juliet.