Oceanic 815 knocked down the statue!
If anyone looks up the site lostipedia. Look at the top of the screen, there is a picture of the island, at the edge of the island we see oceanic 815 crashing, then notice if you change pages there’s a statue in place of oceanic 815.

if this is true then there would be bits of the statue lying around the island. i believe that the island is a symbol of jacob . when we see him at the beginning of the series 5 finale the statue is full and when he dies its just a foot.
I think someone used the dynamite on it. I hope the black rock (if it was indeed carrying the dynamite and it wasnt the DI’s)arrived after 1867, otherwise the writers are setting themselves up for a massive continuity error – dynamite didnt exist then. I reckon Fakob convinced some of the Black Rock crew to do it, but either way i think the dynamite was involved.
I dont think there gonna set themselves up for a continuity error, they obviously had an answer for the statue plot to come up with it in the first place and its been shown throughout the season, they obviously have a plan for it, it is so special to them
I dont think the plane hit it, because you see the plane come falling in from way up high, no where near the statue.
I agree with Matt…if the statue was knocked down or something along those lines then it would be on the island