Written 3rd February
After last night’s episode we know there are two timelines. Â I think when Juliet was dying she was trapped between both… and thus knew the H bomb worked. Â My theory is that both of these are happening at the same time and when a person dies on the Island, they live their life in the new reality, where the plane never crashed. Â I also think the new reality is not “normal”. Â For example, Â Jack still has the cut on his neck and he recognized desmond; Â I believe he also recognized other people from the island. Â Furthermore, Desmond just disappeared and Hurley said he was the luckiest person in the world but even before the plane crash he had bad luck.