Jacob, Flocke, the Island, Hell, and Whatever Else I Think Of

This is my big theory. It will contain everything I believe about LOST so far. Based on last night’s episode, I think this will be good.

Background Information
The Island – The Island itself is an amazing place. It holds down an immense store of evil, preventing it from unleasing Hell on earth and destroying the good in everyone. This evil is burried under the Island, and is held back by two massive stores of energy. The Island moves and hides to prevent anyone from unleashing the evil upon an unsuspecting world.
The Protector – The Protector of the Island has one job: make sure the evil stays on the Island. To do this, he has special powers, such as natural immortality (I use this term to distinguish it from absolute immortality. Natural immortality prevents a natural death, while absolute immortality prevents both natural and man-caused death), healing, the ability to influence people’s thoughts, and the Touch are all I’m sure of.
The Touch – What is the Touch? The Touch is the ability of the Protector to gift others to aid in protecting the Island. This gift can come in different forms, depending on the person it is given to and the person giving it.
The Story of Jacob and Flocke
Jacob is the son of a previous Protector, but not the oldest. His older brother, Flocke, was to become the next Protector. (Alt. version: Jacob is the Protector’s nephew, and Flocke is the Protector’s son) His mother, however, distrusted Flocke. She thought that he shouldn’t become the next Protector, and set out to give that title to Jacob (either her younger son or nephew). She tricked Jacob and Flocke into going to play down by the Frozen Donkey Wheel (it was made ages before as a “faucet” for one of the energy pockets). Not knowing that is was connected to one of the energy pockets trapping the evil, Flocke turned it. This let out an enormous amount of energy, giving the Island its special properties, but also letting out the evil from beneath the Island.
This evil came out in the form of black smoke, and killed Flocke. With Flocke dead, his mother quickly pushed for Jacob to become the next Protector. The title was granted, and Jacob inherited his powers. Unfortunately, they soon found that Flocke had returned. The evil had revived Flocke’s body and taken it. The new, evil Flocke awoke to find that his “crazy” mother had helped set up his brother/cousin as the new Protector. This made him furious. He turned into the Smoke Monster and killed everyone but Jacob. Because Jacob was the Protector, Flocke was not allowed to kill him. In Flocke’s eyes, Jacob had something to do with the scheme his mother has devised, and thus he felt betrayed. The evil in him gave him a more important resolve, though, and that was to escape the Island and corrupt the world.
Jacob quickly discovered what had happened, and decided to hold Flocke on the Island. When he realized the plot made by Flocke’s mother, he was appalled. Unfortunately, he couldn’t give the title back to Flocke, him being evil. From that point on, Jacob and Flocke were locked in a strong disagreement. Flocke, being evil itself, felt that all man was inherently evil and would ultimately live a life of sin. I want to clarify here that the belief isn’t evil, and doesn’t make one evil. However, it is like the liar’s suspicion. If one lies a lot, he distrusts everyone. In the same way, if one is evil, he feels that others are also evil. Jacob believed that, even though man did wrong, he was ultimately capable of rising above and being good. This caused Jacob to begin bringing men to the Island so as to prove man’s goodness, possibly holding Flocke back and decreasing his power. Finally, we reach the season five finale scene. The Black Rock lands, and Flocke’s escape plan begins.
The First Candidate
When Richard comes to the Island, Flocke believes he has found a loophole. He attempts to manipulate Richard into killing Jacob, which fails. At this point, Jacob realizes that he can’t stop Flocke forever. He decided he needs to be ready in case he dies. By offering Richard the job and by Touching (not just touching, such as the fight, but the Touch after Richard’s request) him, he nominated Richard as the first candidate to replace him.
Flocke’s Plan
Later, Flocke’s form became too old. Having died, it wasn’t exactly in shape to live forever. Thus, he decided to find a new form. Having gained his body-cloning powers by being the Smoke Monster, he looked for a new body. He tried many, such as some from the Black Rock and eventually DHARMA, he was not satisfied. He wanted one he knew he could use to make his loophole. Finally, he saw Locke. Locke had just flashed when Flocke saw him. He began following, and took the form of a dead Other to watch. Eventually, he ssaw Locke’s conversation with Richard, telling him to see him once he’s born. Flocke decided that Locke was his target. So he begins scheming. Jacob also saw Locke, but took little interest.
The Losties
In 1974, Jacob found the time-travelling Losties in DHARMA. He realized at that moment that something was going on. He knew that the FDW would be pushed one day, and that the only person who could be behind such a thing would be Flocke. Pushing the FDW again would allow Flocke to grow to full strength, dispel some of the Island’s ability to protect itself, and ultimately allow the death of Jacob. Jacob left the Island and began Touching people, based on their situation. In ’77, he Touched some more people.
Before I go to 2004, let me speak on DHARMA. They found the Island by accident in a sub in the 1950s, and quickly discovered its unique properties. The two pockets of energy intrigued them, and they built the Orchid and Swan to study them. Early on, they turned the FDW, and discovered the Island’s time-travelling abilities. Unfortunately, this awakened the at-this-time inactive Flocke, and thus they had to construct the sonic fence. After the Incident, the other energy pocket was unleashed, allowing Flocke free reign on the Island until the button was created. The blockage of energy with the button prevented Flocke from ever becoming too powerful at one time.
In 2004, Desmond failed to push the button. This signalled Flocke that it was time for him to manipulate. Jacob knew his time was short when Desmond first arrived (he realized that Desmond was already important because of his relationship with Charles Whidmore), and thus used him to bring Ocean 815. He quickly began working to narrow down his replacement. As Jacob worked, Flocke found Christian’s coffin. He destroyed Christian’s body and began using his form to manipulate the Losties. After Desmond turned the fail-safe key, all of the energy restricting Flocke dissipated. With no more restrictions on his power, the only thing getting in the way for him was the rule (this rule was established in the Island’s beginning): he couldn’t kill Jacob. Using his newfound power, he eventually made Ben and Locke turn the FDW, which eventually gave Flocke his new body as Locke.
So, now, Jacob works from beyond the grave to quickly get himself replaced and stop Flocke from leaving the Island. If Flocke does leave the Island, the Island itself will fall into destruction and essentially become Hell itself, while the rest of the world becomes infected by the evil from Flocke.
Answers to Important Questions
Wharfrat77 asked some good questions for this theory, and here are the answers:
“Who was in charge of the others during the Purge? MIB or Jacob” – In this theory, the Purge was the work of Flocke. He’d already seen Locke and was plotting his loophole, but realized that he couldn’t do everything with DHARMA and without Ben. To achieve this, he made sure Ben “wound up” inspecting the Tempest, where he would come begin plotting to kill DHARMA and join the others.
“if MIB, How did he trick the others to follow him? When did they start following him?” – All he needed was Ben. By tricking Ben, he got Ben to trick the Others.
“Where is Jacob at the time?” – Jacob was off-island Touching candidates.
“Did he bring DHARMA to the island?” – Jacob brought DHARMA to the Island in hopes of using them to permanently secure Flocke, but instead, Flocke tricked them into turning the FDW.

Share with fellow Losties

Written by

Mixen Dixon

Hey, I'm Mixen Dixon. I'm a somewhat nerdy teenager, being very enthusiastic about theoretical physics and computers (check me out on LOST is one of my favorite shows. I love to figure out scientific explanations of things that occur in LOST, which is why Daniel Faraday was my fav. character until he died. Too bad.

10 thoughts on “Jacob, Flocke, the Island, Hell, and Whatever Else I Think Of

  1. Mixen Dixon, firstly I would like to say that this is one of the best theories I have read! You have an uncanny ability to tell a story.

    I really like how you have expressed your thoughts, ideas and theory. You have done so in an articulate and simplistic manner and provided us with a thoroughly enjoyable read!

    I believe much of what you have expressed to be true, and feel that what you have speculated upon for the future sounds very intriguing.

    Congrats! This definitely has a ‘wow’ factor.

  2. This also could explain why Widmore is coming to the island with scientists – so he can reconstruct that electromagnetic shield that dissipated when Desmond turned the failsafe. Then he will have control over the smoke monster and the island. This is what he is trying to accomplish.

    This is most likely what he was trying to do with the Kahana scientists as well.

  3. Great thoughts! Here are some things i thought of while reading this…

    Why couldn’t Flocke kill Jacob? I think you said he wasn’t “allowed”, but what does that mean? Is it just against “the rules” or can he physically not kill him?

    “When Oceanic 815 crashed, Jacob knew his time was short.”-Didn’t Jacob bring the plane to the island? He’s been following the Oceanic 6 from their childhood. But it also seems like Desmond failing to press the button caused the plane to crash.

    Jacob continued to bring people to thet island because he believed Flocke could not corrupt any of them into killing him. So it’s kind of like a game to Jacob, gambling his own life.

    Why is Flocke evil? He simply believes that humans are sinful by nature. Does that make him bad? Maybe the smoke is the human MIB’s soul, captured on the island. The smoke monster needs to be in a body to leave the island, and he needs to leave the island so his soul can move on (to heaven or wherever).

    Other thoughts not really relating to your theory but something i’m thinking about:

    Why does Jacob have the power to keep Flocke on the island when he is alive? In the last episode Jacob said that the island is the cork and hell is the wine, but maybe Jacob is more the cork and Flocke is the wine, he can’t get out until Jacob is out of the way. The significance of MIB smashing the bottle is releasing darkness into the world, but without removing the cork…?

  4. Very good, i take it you where inspired by the bible story of Jacob and Esau. There may be some type of yin/yang thing going on and that is the reason why they cannot kill each other. Yin cannot exist without yang.

    There is a ton of evidence that the MIB was trying to get John Locke away from the hatch and button (Ekos stick, odd dreams, visions, ect.). The quicker MIB could get locke to the others, the quicker he would have met Ben, then the FDW, and so on… until the MIB could finally take over Lockes body and complete his loophole.

    I also think that MIB started his loophole when a time traveling Locke prophesied his own coming in the 50’s.

    My big questions for you are:
    Who was in charge of the others during the Purge? MIB or Jacob
    if MIB, How did he trick the others to follow him?
    When did they start following him?
    Where is Jacob at the time?
    If Jacob, Why would he kill all of those people if he is “Good”?
    Did he bring DHARMA to the island?

    Why wouldn’t Jacob let Richard know to watch out for MIB and Flocke before Ben killed him? Wouldnt Jacob know about a time traveling Locke? Why would Jacob have Locke kill his own father?
    I know you will say Jacob and the greater good and all but alot of the moves the others have made have been suspect all in the name of Jacob.

    I tend to think Christian is on the side of MIB but still not positive that Christian IS the MIB. 1. Llana said Flocke couldn’t take any other form(other than smokie) but we see Christian tell Sun and Lapidis to wait for Flocke. 2.Christian appeared to michael on the freighter before it exploded, isn’t the Freighter off the island and at very least outside of the magnetic bubble?

    all in all, a very good read. 5 stars

  5. wasnt dharma founded by the hanso family? if so hanso fam owned the black rock and all them ships. so i dont think dharma found it by accident…… its late and i am tired so if i am wrong i apologize.

  6. Excellent Theory.
    My only thoughts are that the lighthouse with the 360 candidates does not fit in with the theory. also jacob knew that all our losties would be on it so he brought it to the island and knew desmond would not push the button. so why would he have to hurry whe it crashed???

  7. The best theorie i have ever read about the whole story. Well done

    Only bad point i would say was that Jacob brought 815 to the island so knew that Desmond wouldnt press the button.

  8. Wow this was really some read.

    I dont know if i agree with everything but that aside you have done well to back yourself up on your points.

    Some of your ideas a pretty far out there, but i think that is what makes this theory so good. You werent afraid to really dive in and find a story.

    So once again, great post!

Leave a Reply